TW200 Forum banner

1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,142 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
I think my battery is on the way out. I have bought 3 batteries in the last 3 years. Two failed to hold a load after a few months and the third, a friend ruined with a battery charger he hooked up for me and accidently switched it to 6 volts.

Question is, are these really the best? I see they have a 5 year guarantee on their website. I'm tired having to go get batteries.

Can I use my regular charger? It charges from 0 to 1.5 amps.

I also read about cold weather starting and to let the battery warm up a little by leaving the headlight on for a little while before cranking it over. In my case, the headlight does not come on unless the engine is running, so that isn't an option.

These cost as much as the three batteries I bought over the last 3 years.

I do like the fact that they have many more cold cranking amps than the stockers and folks also say they crank over faster.

Opinions?

I'm looking at their #LFX09L2-BS12 Is this what you would use?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,451 Posts
I also have had good results from the cheap old stock battery. I believe members here "charge" their batteries far more than necessary. My stock battery held up to four years "three full years of riding" while never seeing a heated garage or a battery charger. Furthermore, I believe that I can recondition that battery and get further life out of it in an emergency. I am going to document my results when I attempt to resuscitate that old battery providing all of the cells are still good.


Tom
 
  • Like
Reactions: littletommy

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,865 Posts
One of the advantages of lifepo4 lithiums or most any lithium battery is they don't sulfate so there is no need to trickle charge. Another is it doesn't hurt the battery to sit in a partially discharged state whereas a Lead acid battery will sulfate reducing it's capacity. A third advantage is they have a fairly low rate of self discharge which means they can sit with out being charged for long periods of time. So this means you can let them sit over winter and still start your bike with out charging them. And unlike LA batteries their voltage stays high until the capacity is almost out which makes for excellent starting plus they have high current discharge rates until the end of capacity. Now add in a cycle life of 3 times longer. These are dramatic advantages. What are the disadvantages, you can kill them by over discharging them or running them all the way down. If you left your key on or some devise that drains them like a usb outlet could ruin them. Overcharging could damage them voltage over 15v. Most of these batteries have protection circuits in them to prevent these negatives. Another disadvantage is cost but the benefit to cost ratio is more than worth it. These batteries could easily last more than 7 years. In my mind it's a no brainer.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,405 Posts
Here is my .02. I personally do not think Shorai is the end all be all in batteries. I personally have found a couple of drawbacks that will probably keep me from buying another one. What i have found is these batteries do not like to have even the smallest amount of constant discharge. My Ducati is a prime example of this, the computer has a very small constant current that is measured in milliamps. When i had the Shorai in mine it would kill it in under two weeks of sitting. If i left it on a trickle charger the charger would never actually kick on unless i unplugged it and plugged it back in again. The only other recourse i had was to disconnect the battery but that is a pain and having to reset all the custom settings every time i rode it would be a total drag. The other big drawback was cold. Any time the temps dropped overnight the battery would not even light the bike. I know all about the "warmup" procedure but it was useless when the bike would not do anything. The Ducati has an all electronic ignition and it would not even light the dash, it was not a cranking issue but a stone cold dead issue. I literally experienced this having it sit overnight, i could ride all day, park it overnight and it was dead. After a few of these episodes it damaged the battery and Shorai would not warranty it so ~200 wasted and in the bin it went. It lasted a grand total of 3 months of use in that bike, i ended up going back to the stock battery since that worked fine for damn near 5 years before it died of old age.

That said i do have a Shorai in my TW that i ride and in that bike it works ok, not sure i would buy another but it works ok .That bike does not have a constant discharge so it can sit a while untouched and still crank the bike. My girlfriends TW has an Exide AGM battery in it and it works every bit as well as the Shorai at 1/3 the cost, cranks just as good and can sit for long periods of time without discharging. Her bike is not ridden frequently and it has never once been on a charger in 3 years. I just fired it up the other day after a long winters nap and it cranked with authority like it always does.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,369 Posts
My bike: 1997 TW200. Shorai LFX09L2-2002 BOMBARDIER DS50. installed Feb. 2012.

Never has been on a tender, ever. Bike is seldom rode, and often sits for a month or 3 without being moved, touched, etc.

Five years on now, it has never gone dead, cranks the engine over quickly weather hot or cold.

No acid to spill, no corroded cable ends. Just works!

Conclusion, Mike-E-Like-E! :D Nuf said. m.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,369 Posts
Here is my .02. I personally do not think Shorai is the end all be all in batteries. I personally have found a couple of drawbacks that will probably keep me from buying another one. What i have found is these batteries do not like to have even the smallest amount of constant discharge. My Ducati is a prime example of this, the computer has a very small constant current that is measured in milliamps. When i had the Shorai in mine it would kill it in under two weeks of sitting. If i left it on a trickle charger the charger would never actually kick on unless i unplugged it and plugged it back in again. The only other recourse i had was to disconnect the battery but that is a pain and having to reset all the custom settings every time i rode it would be a total drag. The other big drawback was cold. Any time the temps dropped overnight the battery would not even light the bike. I know all about the "warmup" procedure but it was useless when the bike would not do anything. The Ducati has an all electronic ignition and it would not even light the dash, it was not a cranking issue but a stone cold dead issue. I literally experienced this having it sit overnight, i could ride all day, park it overnight and it was dead. After a few of these episodes it damaged the battery and Shorai would not warranty it so ~200 wasted and in the bin it went. It lasted a grand total of 3 months of use in that bike, i ended up going back to the stock battery since that worked fine for damn near 5 years before it died of old age.

That said i do have a Shorai in my TW that i ride and in that bike it works ok, not sure i would buy another but it works ok .That bike does not have a constant discharge so it can sit a while untouched and still crank the bike. My girlfriends TW has an Exide AGM battery in it and it works every bit as well as the Shorai at 1/3 the cost, cranks just as good and can sit for long periods of time without discharging. Her bike is not ridden frequently and it has never once been on a charger in 3 years. I just fired it up the other day after a long winters nap and it cranked with authority like it always does.
Having said what I said above, I have to concur with jb882. The Lith battery will suffer from constant drain conditions. Many vehicles & other devices that use Lith batteries will have something that needs continual power, and the battery will only perform well if the device is used (and thus recharged) frequently, motorcycles included. Most TW's have no off condition drain, & so a lith battery will work well.

I also think it sucks that Shorai would not stand behind your failed battery. :( m.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
515 Posts
Well here is my 3 cents worth...

If you TW charge voltage exceeds 14.9 I would not use one of these batteries.... The spec says 15.2 max but I would not like to push at or near spec...

If you charge voltage is at 14.8 or higher a Flooded Wet Cell battery is going to be boiling almost all the time the bike is running... That will eat a battery quite quick. Even an AGM can not handle a constant 14.8

I have not checked my TW charge voltage in quite a while and do not recall what that voltage was..

LFX09L2-BS12 - Shorai Lithium Batteries

SHORAI LFX Lithium-Iron Powersports battery, 9Ah PbEq 12V eq, "L" polarity, Case Type 2 Length 4.45" Width 2.28" Height 3.50" Shorai Batteries require a charging system output of 13.1 Volts or higher at idle, and must not exceed 15.2 volts at maximum output.
Jim
 
  • Like
Reactions: littletommy

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,142 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
I do have an alarm on the bike which when on, drains it slowly.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,172 Posts
I had called Battery Tender and ordered a battery and charger from Amazon before I read this thread. I will be the test dummy for a Battery Tender Lithium batteries.

3 year warranty Lithium Battery
P/N BTL09A120C $112


Charger 800 JR $38.99
P/N 022-0199

I just spent all my Birthday money :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,451 Posts
I had called Battery Tender and ordered a battery and charger from Amazon before I read this thread. I will be the test dummy for a Battery Tender Lithium batteries.

3 year warranty Lithium Battery
P/N BTL09A120C $112


Charger 800 JR $38.99
P/N 022-0199

I just spent all my Birthday money :)
I could purchase 8 of the new batteries I just installed for that much money! Ouch.



Tom
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,172 Posts
I bought my 2 BT Lithiums from an Ebay seller for $79.99 each. I also checked my charge voltage, 13.7 at idle, and a steady 14.2 at 1,600 and higher RPM on the '13. Used my BT Junior charger to do the initial charge.
Keep your receipts when I talked to BT customer support today he said they have a no hassle 3 year warranty
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
172 Posts
Just did the Battery Tender battery just like scotti158. $80. Customer support concurred that the battery tender jr will charge up the battery safely so I skipped the lithium charger. Battery seems great. No cranking the engine. I just push the button and it is running. I swear it is like instant on. Been very happy so far. Time will tell. My old lead acid wouldn't reliably start at 12.4 and I would only get one start after charging up to 12.8 or 12.9. Also think my lights are brighter but may just be trying to make myself feel better about spending cash. Was tempted to go next size up but was unsure as the dimensions say that the battery is 5.27 inches wide. I though I remember someone on here saying that they went with the next size up, can't recall who? How did it fit?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ken and littletommy

·
Registered
Joined
·
128 Posts
I think my battery is on the way out. I have bought 3 batteries in the last 3 years. Two failed to hold a load after a few months and the third, a friend ruined with a battery charger he hooked up for me and accidently switched it to 6 volts.

Question is, are these really the best? I see they have a 5 year guarantee on their website. I'm tired having to go get batteries.

Can I use my regular charger? It charges from 0 to 1.5 amps.

I also read about cold weather starting and to let the battery warm up a little by leaving the headlight on for a little while before cranking it over. In my case, the headlight does not come on unless the engine is running, so that isn't an option.

These cost as much as the three batteries I bought over the last 3 years.

I do like the fact that they have many more cold cranking amps than the stockers and folks also say they crank over faster.

Opinions?

I'm looking at their #LFX09L2-BS12 Is this what you would use?
I bought the LFX14L2-BS12 Extreme - have a few accessories and it works great. Colds starts like a champ and I never leave headlights to on to warm it up. Bought because my stock battery struggled in cold. I bought the lithium battery tender because I occ leave my lights on and run my battery dead. No complaints only good things.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
286 Posts
I've always wanted a shorai but after reading how their customer service is I'm changing my mind. Now you guys are starting to convince me that battery tender lithiums are the way to go. You could buy two for the price of the shorai and it sounds like they do have good customer support. I like the cca of 120, it's a decent amount higher than my agm which only has 80 cca.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top